Monday, November 2, 2015

Argument Essay Resources

Should College Athletes Be Paid? 

Yes

The Case for Paying College Athletes by Marc Edelman

College Athletes Should Be Compensated: Former UCLA Star by Michelle Fox

March Madness: Is John Oliver Right? Should NCAA Pay College Athletes? By Alexander LaCosse

No

The NCAA Would Be Making a Mistake by Paying Athletes by Andrew Merkle

College Athletes Shouldn't be Paid by Kieran McCauley

Students Are Not Professional Athletes by Horace Mitchell

Extras

A neutral 4 minute video overview from CNN: Should the NCAA pay college players?

Multiple shorter responses for each side in US News and World Reports Debate Club: Should NCAA Athletes Be Paid?

Article + Video from the Huffington PostObama Calls on NCAA to Rethink the Way it Protects and Punishes Athletes

Economists and the Huffington Post Research the Issue: NCAA Schools Can Absolutely Afford to Pay College Athletes

A long, fascinating, advanced look at the issue from The Atlantic: The Shame of College Sports


Does social media make us less social? 

Yes

Social Network and its Effect on Communication by thaiatzickas in Teen Ink 

Disruptions: More Connected, Yet More Alone by Nick Bilton in the New York Times

Teens and Social Media by Rachel Ehmke

No

The Upside of Selfies by Kelly Wallace at CNN 

 How Technology Makes Us Better Social Beings by Megan Gambino in Smithsonion.com

Teens, Technology and Friendships by Amanda Lenhart at Pew Research Center  

Extras/Videos


Do we need a law against catcalling?
Telling Our Stories to Change the Culture of Harrassment by Tatyana Fazlalizadeh in the New York Times 
Becoming the Symbol of Street Harrassment by Shoshana B. Roberts in the New York Times
Street Harrassment Law Would Restrict Intimidating Behavior by Laura Beth Nielsen in the New York Times 
No
Don't Outlaw Catcalling by Conor Friedersdorf in The Atlantic 
Legistlating Catcalling Comes with Real Risks by Gabe Rottman in the New York Times

Neutral
Website of hollaback!, a non-profit focused on ending street harassment, provides general statistics showing how many women are harassed; this source does not mention legal action
Article explaining what sexual harassment and catcalling are from CNN

Extras/Videos
Neutral article defining the problem: http://www.cnn.com/2012/10/06/living/street-harassment/
Catcalling is not a crime: http://nypost.com/2014/11/03/catcalling-vile-but-not-a-crime/
In Peru, government passed a law making it illegal to catcall: 
http://hellogiggles.com/street-harassment-peru/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RDpaX_KhWSk

Should Food Containing GMOs be labeled?
Overview
To Label or Not to Label by Richard Dahl
Should Companies be Required to Label Genetically Modified Foods? by The Wall Street Journal

Yes
Should GMOs be labeled? by Amir Khan
Why We Should Accept GMO Labels by Dan Fagin

No
Labels for GMO Foods are a Bad Idea by The Editors of Scientific American
House Passes Bill to Prevent Mandatory GMO Food Labeling by Mary Clare Jalonick

Extras/Videos
"Why genetically engineered foods should be labeled:  TEDXManhattan 2013"

"GMO Food Labeling:  inside the controversy"

"Congress Moves to Stop States from Requiring GMO Labeling"

Should people eat meat? 
Neutral/Overview
Should We Eat Meat? by Karen Weintraub for the Boston Globe
Should Humans Eat Meat? by Vaclov Smil by for Scientific American
No

Why You Shouldn't Eat Meat by Janeyy, a teen author for Teen Ink


Yes

Do Happy, Healthy Brains Need Meat? by Drew Ramsey in Psychology Today

Give Thanks for Meat by James Bost in the New York Times

Is There Enough Meat for Everyone by Bill Gates in Gates Notes

Additional Resources for this topic: 

Videos: 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gx8y32oaFQI A video attempting to DISPROVE the claim that humans are NOT designed to eat meat
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ti-WcnqUwLM Renowned philosopher Peter Singer on the ethics of eating meat
http://www.wnyc.org/story/205842-ethics-eating-meat/ - The Ethicist's editor, Ariel Kaminer, discusses the NY Times essay contest on the ethics of meat-eating on The Brian Lehrer show on NPR
https://www.ted.com/talks/mark_bittman_on_what_s_wrong_with_what_we_eat?language=en - NY Times food writer Mark Bittman discusses the effects of what we eat on the environment and society
Articles: 
Don't Feel Guilty for Eating Meat from Time.com: http://time.com/97479/carnivore-vegetarian-animals-meat/
A balanced and thoughtful argument on why eating meat is not wrong: http://brighterbrains.org/articles/entry/why-it-isnt-wrong-to-eat-meat

Other considerations: does it matter what kind of animal it is? 

Happy Halloween from 116!